The 176 bodies have apparently been retrieved, including those of 57 Canadians whose lives were so brutally ended as they were on their way home.
The Iranian military has admitted that they were responsible.
And said that they are very sorry for bringing down the plane with a missile, in the fog or the darkness of war.
Leaving Justin Trudeau in the darkness of an Ottawa winter having to deal with the diplomatic fallout, and the anger and grief of many Canadians.
And doing in my opinion an incredible job.
For while I'm glad he has let the Iranians know that he is "outraged and furious" and is demanding a full and transparent investigation to explain how something like this could have happened...
I'm also pleased to see that he is not letting that anger get out of control. He is still calling for de-escalation. and not trying to score cheap political points by using blind rage as a weapon
And I'm also pleased that as Aaron Wherry points out, Trudeau is drawing on his inner strength to reach out to grieving Canadians.
Trudeau's greatest natural advantages as a politician have been his lifelong connection with the Canadian public and his own inclination to connect and so it might seem to naturally follow that he would orient himself toward the personal needs of those directly affected. He spent much of Friday meeting with grieving families and made a point of relaying their feelings and desires in his prepared remarks on Saturday.
"They are hurt, angry and grieving," Trudeau said. "They want answers. They want justice."
So he has been attending vigils to honour and remember the dead.
And trying to console their grieving relatives like Shahin Moghaddam in Toronto who lost his wife and young son.
Moghaddam told Global News that Rosstin, a Grade 4 student at Beynon Fields public school in Richmond Hill, always said he wanted to be Justin Trudeau when he grew up. He said the prime minister asked him about his son’s career aspirations.
“I told him the same thing. He cried with me. He’s such a great man. I don’t know anything about his politics, but personally, he’s a great man,” Moghanddam said as tears streamed down his face, adding he thinks that Rosstin was watching from heaven today.
It has been an incredible display of smart diplomacy, strength, empathy, and of the differences that make us Canadians not Americans.
So I was disgusted to see that some members of the Con media, like Heather Scoffield, feel that Trudeau hasn't been angry enough.
Justin Trudeau was subdued Thursday when he said an Iranian missile probably caused the plane crash that killed 63 Canadians. Sure, he expressed sympathy for the families of the victims, but there was also weariness in his call for Canada to be included in the investigation into how those innocent passengers were killed.
Where was the indignation?
With Scoffield answering her own question, only to sound ridiculous.
Would indignation work any better?
Maybe not — but at least we’d be telling Trump that we see his recklessness for what it is. And this week, it would certainly have reflected the mood of an angry and grieving nation.
And ending up, in my opinion, sounding hysterical.
For what good would it do to scream at Donald Trump for having started the cycle of violence with his reckless assassination of a top Iranian leader?This column is hysterical garbage.Trudeau has handled relations with the maniac Trump better than any other leader. And has shown the empathy and class I expect from a Canadian prime minister. https://t.co/h78VQBTYBV via @torontostar— π¨π¦ Simon π΄σ §σ ’σ ³σ £σ ΄σ Ώ ππ (@montrealsimon) January 11, 2020
When his own people will hold the orange maniac in the White House accountable.
Americans by more than 2-1 said the killing of Iranian Gen. Qasem Soleimani has made the United States less safe, a nationwide USA TODAY/Ipsos Poll finds, amid broad concerns about the potential consequences ahead.
A majority of those surveyed, by 52%-34%, called President Donald Trump's behavior with Iran "reckless."
And the world needs another leader screaming for bloody revenge, like it needs a hole in the head.
For that is NOT the Canadian way.
And even some of Trudeau's most savage critics now seem to recognize that our young prime minister has risen to the occasion.
Which may surprise some of you but doesn't surprise me.
The vile Cons and their media stooges have tried to destroy Justin Trudeau in many disgusting ways.
But as the old saying goes, what doesn't kill you makes you stronger.
In this time of war and tragedy Trudeau is the leader we need.
And all good and decent Canadians can be proud of him...
I'm so sorry Canada. Justin Trudeau is really the leader that the world needs right now, and I plead with Canadians to keep him in his position for as long as is humanly possible.
ReplyDeleteI promise that I and my fellow Americans will do everything we can to ensure that this orange boil on the body politic is excised from office in November. I can't promise the outcome but I can ensure that there will be a massive effort to do so.
Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called the children of God. (Matthew 5:9)
BTW Susan Delacourt has a much more sober take
Deletehttps://www.thestar.com/politics/political-opinion/2020/01/11/trudeaus-fury-with-iran-after-plane-crash-couched-in-language-of-diplomacy.html
I don't know what's happening to the Star it used to be a progressive paper but it's as Con as they come these days. The article was riddled with errors and made no sense. Canadians are supposed to go as crazy as Americans and declare war on Iran? Good for Trudeau for acting like as a Canadian instead of a Con.
Delete"I and my fellow Americans..."
DeleteDo not make promises you cannot keep. A minority of you will at best.
Hopefully it is enough though.
Do not imagine all of us will soon forget that after you got dozens of our citizens murdered your president's official response was, "All is well."
HI Jackie....I read Delacourt's column and I was really impressed by how well the Liberal team is working. They were on it right from the beginning, and Trudeau's more subdued style plays well into this new approach. I wasn't sure about the beard, but whatever works is fine with me....π
DeleteHi anon @3:03 PM....I don't know why the Star is more right wing these days. I think it's because they now sell papers out west so they are tailoring their coverage accordingly. The Star like other media outfits is in terrible financial shape so one can hardly blame them if they're desperate. But it is disappointing....
DeleteHi Sixth Estate....Trump can pretend he is the victor of this latest Middle East horror show, but that won't last. The Iranians may have concluded their opening act, but it will be soon be replaced by one attack after the other on U.S. targets in Iraq. And Trump's nightmare will begin....
DeleteSimon -- I take your point about image politics but my point is that this should serve as an important wake-up call. Our supposedly strongest ally's officially stated policy is that the mass death of Canadians by violence is a sign of things going "well."
Delete"Do not imagine all of us will soon forget that after you got dozens of our citizens murdered your president's official response was, "All is well.""
DeleteThat's a rather rude comment at someone trying to offer some comfort for something she and most Americans are against and had nothing to do with. Kindly direct your vitriol where it belongs, Trump and those who enable him and feel free to apologize for equating decent Americans with that lump of shit in the oval office.
JD
“I told him the same thing. He cried with me. He’s such a great man."
ReplyDeleteIt's heartbreaking to see that dear man holding the picture of his wife and child, knowing his entire world has been shattered by this senseless, needless tragedy and it's no surprise that Justin would be moved to tears by this.
You are absolutely right, Simon. Our PM has handled this with tact and a genuine compassion rarely seen from world leaders so any Con or Con hack who thinks he should have went all "Fire and Fury" over this need to just shut up. Let the adults run this country as it should be run and if you dont have anything nice to say that could bring any semblance of peace and solace to the grieving families, then please, say nothing at all.
JD
Xavier is about the same age as Mr. Moghaddam's son and Justin was probably thinking of his own kids, father to father. I would venture that flashes of memories of Michel's tragic death, and the devastating impact it had on both Margaret and Pierre, both of ailing health in their own ways, might have come to his mind as well. There is no greater pain than a parent burying a child.
DeleteIt's what Obama was referring to when he spoke of Trayvon Martin as the son he never had. Like Trudeau, he was also relentlessly and cruelly mocked by Republicans for it. The party of "think of the children," mind you. Their inbred Con-adian cousins are no better.
Trump and the ayatollah, in their senseless dick-measuring contest, might have killed a future prime minister. Anyone who says that Trudeau's grief and empathy aren't genuine, or that he was just "acting" and "relying on his drama training," deserves a special place in hell.
HI JD....Yes, that was a really heartbreaking story, and only Trudeau could have comforted that poor man like he did. He met with other families in Toronto as well and is at another memorial in Edmonton tonight. It must be a huge emotional strain but somehow he manages it, and that's part of what makes him such a great Canadian prime minister. I read recently that when that Air India plane was blown out of the sky the Indo Canadians who died were treated like they weren't real Canadians. So I think Trudeau is doing his best to make sure that doesn't happen again. So Scoffield's claim that he isn't angry enough is completely out of line, and she should be ashamed of herself...
DeleteYes, I remember that and how the victims seemed to be relegated to "people from India". And years later, the FLQ crisis was described on a CBC (!) poster as the "worst terrorist act in Canadian history". I was furious and wrote in to them. The posters disappeared, but there was no rectification. The FLQ cells were rather incompetent terrorists and while their acts were deplorable, in no way did they equal the loss of lives in the Air India bombing.
DeleteHI lagatta....yes, the coverage of the FLQ crisis was as shallow and devoid of any understanding of Quebec as could be. And comparing the bumbling FLQ to those who brought down Air India, isn't just absurd, it's obscene...
DeleteFcuk Warren and Simon I wonder about your editorial process. There is no good or bad leader in this situation.
ReplyDeleteHi Steve....Call Kinsella what you like, but what do you mean you wonder about my editorial process? And I'm sorry but I don't agree. There are good and bad leaders in every situation. And leaders who share our Canadian values and those who don't. If we can't tell the difference we could lose our country....
DeleteHi Simon, my apologizes I did not have a chortler argument to call you out.
DeleteI agree with all comments about the Star, like the NYT when push comes to shove they step on the push. Thank you internet Gods who help us realize the truth is out there, but its not going to come from a comfortable place.
ReplyDeleteKinsella isn't the only Con to praise Trudeau, so did the old Postie Robin Urback, and the Con propagandist Stephen Taylor who called Trudeau "prime ministerial." So Trudeau must be doing something right. And if he keeps doing what he is doing the Cons are going to have trouble getting anyone to run for their leadership.
ReplyDeleteHi anon....Yes, if Trudeau can win over those three Cons he must be doing something right. And if he appeals to more Red Tories he could put a dent in the Cons when the time comes for another election. I'm not sure I like a more somber Trudeau, it's too boring for me. But if it can help win another majority I can live with it....π
Deleteyou think they praise him, no they cover their ass
DeleteThe Conservatives in this country will never stop trying to turn us into Americans. And what worries me is that most Canadians either can't see what's happening or don't care.
ReplyDeleteHI anon...it's true that the Cons are now more American than Canadian. But don't worry we're winning, and most Canadians do care. The tweet I included in the post has already received more than 1,700 likes so there are a lot of people who feel like you and me., and we won't let them steal our Canada....
Deletenever going to be an American Idiot, or as my parents used to say, stupid american
DeleteOur political leaders can't change the world overnight but they can influence it in a positive direction and Trudeau does that.
ReplyDeleteAt the same time the repetitive downing of commercial flights in a conflict zone is a tragedy that responsible governments need to address. Iran targeted US bases following repeated threats by Trump that Iran would be hit hard and fast following any attack against Americans yet there was a commercial flight in Iranian air space within an hour afterwards. Perhaps the military leaders were playing some sort of Twitter brinkmanship but the soldiers on the front line view conflict as a life or death struggle and sometimes have to make instant decisions. Its unlikely world leaders will agree to a set of no fly protocols but Canada and other countries could implement a messaging system that warns their citizens when conditions have changed. An algorithm based on news statements and the reported actions of leaders in the conflict could have predicted a code red as soon as it was known that missiles were launched even if it was blinking orange/ red following Soleimani's killing several days before the launch when it was officially stated Iran would counter strike to avenge Soleimini and Trump promised awesome retaliation.
RT
Hi RT.....This whole tragedy is surrealistic in the worst way. The maniac Trump authorizes the killing of a legendary Iranian General because he's terrified of being accused of being too weak to prevent, in his paranoid mind, another BENGHAZI!!!
DeleteThe Mullah regime don't want to look weak, so they fire off missiles at U.S. Bases in Iraq. And then as the Iranian military waits to see what Trump is going to do, a crew in an aging missile launcher, fires at what they believe is a US. drone and down a civilian airliner. Both sides are to blame, but if Trump hadn't taken out that Iranian General for no good reason, chances are everyone on that doomed flight would still be alive...
Whats most interesting is the Cons have not found a way to attack him. Yes they call for making Iran a terrorist organization,but after that crickets.
ReplyDeleteHi Steve....The Cons are itching to attack Trudeau, but Scheer is afraid that people might wonder whose side that Ugly American is on. Our side or Trump's?
ReplyDelete